麻豆影视

Get stories like these delivered straight to your inbox. Sign up for The 74 Newsletter

The debate over the firing of . misses the point: It鈥檚 neither that his tests were too hard nor that his Gen Z students were too entitled. It鈥檚 that introductory courses should be gateways into the STEM professions, especially for students underrepresented in these areas, not elimination rounds in a cutthroat competition in an imagined world of scarcity.

The pandemic has accelerated a workforce crisis in the STEM fields and a persistent gap in science, technology, engineering and math education. Across industries, the . Yet millions of potential professionals from diverse backgrounds are not being tapped. In 2017, while Black, Latino and Native American students comprised 34% of prospective college STEM majors, only 18% of them actually earned a STEM degree. 

The probability that a STEM-focused white male student who receives a C or better in all introductory courses will earn a degree in the field is . But for a similar Black male student, the chances are 31%, while Black female students have just a 28% chance. Yet, there is between those introductory grades and career success or job performance. That early C has no bearing on how good a doctor a student will become. And when it comes to innovators, to success: As grades go down, invention goes up.

To increase the number of women and students of color who will become the country鈥檚 next generation of doctors, engineers, and epidemiologists, educators need to listen to what they really need 鈥� and why they drop out of STEM majors at rates disproportionate to their white male counterparts. A new study called the 鈥� through which 600 diverse young people shared their experiences 鈥� identifies one key ingredient that can either keep students in STEM courses or push them out: a sense of belonging. 

Samantha Guerro, who attended high school in Texas, shared her experience with STEM courses through the story collection project, powered by Beyond100K (formerly 100Kin10). 鈥淚 think a really important part of this spark of interest was the teacher,鈥� Guerro said. 鈥淭hey’re excited to actually teach others, and they want to make you understand.鈥�

Guerro鈥檚 love of science was nurtured by her Advanced Placement chemistry teacher, who made it 鈥渟o that you can feel like this is something you can do. It’s not something reserved for only the elites of academia.鈥� 

That sense of belonging and connection fueled Guerro to persist in STEM through high school. It鈥檚 no different in college. Belonging is correlated to persevering in STEM. And persevering past that first bad grade can make the difference between success and failure.

Most anyone who鈥檚 taken an introductory STEM course knows that one of the first things students hear, whether that course is calculus, computer science, or organic chemistry: 鈥淟ook to your left, look to your right; only one of you will be here by the end of the semester.鈥� 

Such a mindset is not only outdated; it鈥檚 likely to replicate the very inequities and shortages the STEM sector is trying so hard to address. Instead of aiming to weed out students, introductory courses should be designed to create as many pathways to success as possible. By creating classes that prioritize nurturing a sense of belonging for students 鈥� especially those who might be the first in their family to study STEM 鈥� schools won鈥檛 have to choose between high expectations and high success rates.

The field has many bright spots to learn from. The University of Texas at Austin, for example, has focused on fostering belonging as the centerpiece of its to help first-generation college students graduate. First-generation college-goers at UT Austin earn their degrees at a rate of nearly 65%, compared with a national average of 27%. The hallmarks of the program are small classes, peer mentors, tutoring, engaged faculty advisers and community-building. But little things also help: older students record short videos about times they doubted themselves and felt alone, and how they persevered, which reinforces the message that students belong and can succeed. 

In Massachusetts, mandatory at Bridgewater State University not only increased student success in introductory STEM courses, but overall retention in STEM majors. Xavier University in New Orleans, than any other university in the country, uses early quizzes to flag students who need support into tutoring and study groups and encourages peers to help those who need to catch up. University of Maryland, Baltimore County, created an aspiring to STEM careers, primarily kids of color, with high expectations and a strong sense of community.

The common denominator across all these efforts: belonging.

The U.S. Department of Education鈥檚 new initiative to modernize STEM education spotlights this very connection between rigor and belonging. Called , its aim is that all students, no matter their background, get a world-class STEM education to prepare them and the country for the future. To get to that future, students first need to know that they belong and can succeed in STEM.

In no other major is the goal of college introductory courses to scare passionate students away. Why are STEM courses so different? If all students are helped to persevere; if they feel they belong in STEM, whatever their background; if they understand that their unique experiences are essential in bringing forth unique contributions to the fields of science, technology, engineering and math, who knows what inventions, cures and breakthroughs await.

Get stories like these delivered straight to your inbox. Sign up for The 74 Newsletter