麻豆影视

Get stories like these delivered straight to your inbox. Sign up for The 74 Newsletter

At the start of the current school year, Minnesota education officials estimated there were almost 500 open special education teaching jobs throughout the state, or about half of all unfilled positions reported by districts in a voluntary survey. 

At the same time, an analysis by The 74 of Minnesota鈥檚 teacher licensing records found that during the 2022-23 academic year, more than 1,500 licensed special educators 鈥� comprising 16% of teachers credentialed to work with students with disabilities 鈥� chose to work in regular classrooms. 

And more than a fourth of teachers working with students with disabilities 鈥� 27%, or nearly 3,000 鈥� lacked any special education credential. Licensed to teach language arts, social studies, music, health and other general education subjects, in many cases their schools have a state waiver to place them with students with disabilities.

The one-two punch leaves thousands of the state鈥檚 most vulnerable children 鈥� among those hit hardest by the pandemic losses 鈥� without qualified teachers at a crucial juncture. Many received little or none of the specialized instruction they are legally entitled to during COVID鈥檚 school disruptions. They have not bounced back to their dismal pre-pandemic achievement rates of at grade level.

鈥淜ids with disabilities are never the top priority,鈥� says Wendy Tucker, a senior policy fellow at the Center for Learner Equity, which researches and promotes quality in special education. 鈥淭hey just keep getting pushed down the list.鈥� 

Even in normal times, federal civil rights laws require school systems to make up services children with disabilities don鈥檛 receive for whatever reason. But as is the case in many places, the reality in Minnesota is that districts are closing specialized programs or moving kids into makeshift settings. 

To push districts to prioritize a particularly vulnerable subset of children, U.S. civil rights laws don鈥檛 allow school systems to use a shortage of qualified educators to justify denying students with learning differences the services they need to succeed. Disability advocates have long complained that the practice of assigning available but unqualified educators to special education classrooms is illegal because it is a key barrier to students making academic progress. 

It鈥檚 easy to understand why administrators are exhausted meeting the bare-bones goal of having students safe and supervised, Tucker acknowledges, but for kids it鈥檚 the start of a very slippery slope: 鈥淚t鈥檚 a vicious cycle. Low expectations are met, because the supports weren’t there, because there were low expectations.鈥�

Minnesota licensing officials refused to comment on The 74鈥檚 findings about the number of special education teachers choosing not to work in the area or the high rate of jobs being filled by educators lacking special education credentials. When asked about the number of special education teachers who leave their jobs for general education classrooms, Yelena Bailey, executive director of the Professional Educator Licensing and Standards Board, said in an email that the board does not have that information: 鈥淲e do not have attrition rate data due to limitations of our data system. We hope to hire someone in the coming months who can help put this together manually.鈥�

In a , the board has calculated annual attrition rates for teachers overall since 2017, when a new licensing system went into effect. The data shows that nearly a third of all new teachers hired since then leave within five years 鈥� better than the national average 鈥� and includes, where known, their reasons for quitting. 

The report does not include information on special educators who leave. Nor does the licensing board tally actual vacancies overall, instead reporting the percentage of districts that say they have hard-to-fill openings by subject area. In lieu of the number of people schools would have to hire to be fully staffed, it uses the number of educators in all fields with waivers to work outside their licensure area and those with entry-level credentials who are working toward permanent licensure as a proxy. 

When broken down by area of expertise, special education of specialties taught by teachers without appropriate, permanent licenses. Last year, there were 2,000. 

My phone has been ringing off the hook with parents saying, 鈥楳y kid doesn鈥檛 have a teacher, or they have a long-term sub 鈥�

Maren Christenson, executive director of the Multicultural Autism Action Network

A lack of hard numbers outside of the assignment data examined by The 74 makes it impossible to know how many of Minnesota鈥檚 153,000 pre-K-12 children receiving special ed services aren鈥檛 being taught by a qualified educator. Minnesota education advocates have pressed 鈥� unsuccessfully so far 鈥� for laws requiring better data collection.

But news stories and anecdotal accounts from family advocates suggest that the number is at crisis levels. At the start of the year, the state鈥檚 largest system, the Anoka-Hennepin School District, announced it was at least temporarily closing an entire specialized school for some of its most profoundly disabled students. Last year, it had 53 special educators working in general education classrooms, according to licensing records.

Minneapolis Public Schools last year canceled some in-person instruction, moving many disabled pupils back online for summer services 鈥� despite the fact that the extra instruction was needed to make up for ineffective distance learning. Last year, it had 54 teachers licensed to teach in special education that weren鈥檛. The district started this year with disproportionately clustered in its most impoverished schools.

鈥淢y phone has been ringing off the hook with parents saying, 鈥楳y kid doesn鈥檛 have a teacher, or they have a long-term sub or their school is trying to pull something together using the available people in the building,鈥� 鈥� says Maren Christenson, executive director of the Multicultural Autism Action Network, a nonprofit serving Somali and Oromo families in Minnesota. 

鈥淲e were in a crisis before the pandemic,鈥� she says. 鈥淚t鈥檚 really disingenuous of school districts to say they are taken by surprise. We鈥檝e known this was coming for a long time.鈥�

鈥業t鈥檚 not just a pipeline issue鈥�

Inattention to the high rate at which special education teachers quit for easier teaching jobs, say disability advocates, combined with a stop-gap approach to filling the resulting vacancies, make a reckoning about the quality of special education long overdue. Research shows that given proper instruction, most children with disabilities can achieve at grade level. Yet particularly in the wake of the pandemic鈥檚 school closures, when many special ed students were deprived entirely of services, it鈥檚 not clear they鈥檒l have the chance.

According to a small but showing what could keep special educators on the job, a handful of key factors propel many into general education. that 20% of new Washington state teachers who earned both a special education and a regular classroom credential chose not to take a job teaching students with disabilities at all. Other research has found that special educators are than other teachers to leave teaching altogether and 72% more likely to leave a job for one in another school.

Whether the departures are from special ed or from teaching altogether, advocacy groups say the turnover perpetuates the problem, as increased shortages translate to higher caseloads for those who remain, in turn making the job less sustainable. With more jobs to fill, administrators also are more likely to tap teachers who are willing to take them but who lack appropriate licenses.

Dan Goldhaber, vice president of the Center for Analysis of Longitudinal Data in Education Research at the American Institutes for Research, has studied the special educator workforce. The high number of special educators working outside the field documented by The 74鈥檚 analysis echoes his own research, he says. 

“These are not new issues,” says Goldhaber, noting that the ongoing lack of special educators differs from shortfalls in other areas such as science, math, engineering and technology. “In special education, it’s not just a pipeline issue, it’s an attrition issue.”

Minneapolis teacher Tameika Williams made it through one of the pipeline-priming programs officials are counting on to ease the shortage only to find the work impossible, she said. She belongs to the Minnesota chapter of Educators for Excellence, whose leaders have heard enough stories like hers to form a task force on working conditions in special ed. 

A Black woman who grew up without any teachers who looked like her or a sense of belonging in school, Williams said she never envisioned herself as an educator. She was employed by a community organization that supported families when the principal of one of the schools she worked in remarked that Williams had an affinity for connecting with youth with disabilities. A program at a local university would help her get a graduate degree and teaching credential for free. 

As she was earning a master鈥檚, Williams started teaching special ed in Minneapolis Public Schools, working entirely with students of color. She says she logged twice as many hours as she was supposed to. 

After four years, however, Williams was done. When she told her principal she was quitting, he proposed she stay as the teacher in charge of a career-training program that gives students an early jump on becoming educators themselves through early college courses. Her classes now include both students with and without disabilities, but she does not have to deal with the daunting workload she had as a special educator.

The administrator she reported to before she changed jobs, Williams said, had criticized her for insisting on teaching history, saying none of her students were college bound. Williams persisted, though. Understanding the multi-generational impact of inadequate education on students of color and children with disabilities 鈥� material she was not exposed to until college 鈥� was what, Williams said, finally convinced her to get a teaching credential.  

She still harbors ambivalence about the fact that some of her current students with IEPs are considering becoming special education teachers. On the one hand, more educators living with disabilities themselves would boost children receiving special education, now often not educated to be college- or career-ready. On the other, she鈥檚 not confident that they, too, won鈥檛 be pressured to dumb down the curriculum.  

鈥淚’m not gonna lie, I have some conflicting values still around encouraging young Black kids to become teachers,鈥� she says. 鈥淚 have the rooted belief that all kids are capable.鈥�

Stories like Williams鈥檚 are common everywhere, say teachers. The Illinois chapter of the educator advocacy organization Teach Plus has collected information from members who say special education requires radical change to be a sustainable job. 

After seven years in a special education classroom in Chicago Public Schools, Bridget Rood said she was of knowing that she wasn鈥檛 preparing the students in her program, which existed to help them make the transition to adulthood, well for life after school.  

鈥淚 was depressed, I was dysregulated,鈥� she says. 鈥淚 didn鈥檛 feel fulfilled at all. I don鈥檛 think I had one student in those seven years who [went on to job training or more education].鈥�

A Teach Plus fellowship gave Rood both a break and, as she a colleagues conducted , a sense of how pervasive feelings like hers were. Sixty-two percent of special educators they surveyed ranked an acceptable workload as the first- or second-most important thing to them. In addition to teaching, the special educators Teach Plus consulted said they strained to find time to do paperwork, talk to families, create behavior intervention plans and their own curriculum on the fly while also managing support staff. 

After her fellowship, Rood went to work for a more affluent district on Chicago鈥檚 north side, Niles Township High School District 219. More resources means she does not have to scrounge to find curriculum or other instructional resources. She is still responsible for paperwork, but a departmental secretary takes care of a huge number of repetitive, time-consuming tasks, such as making sure the right people are scheduled to attend the meetings where students鈥� plans are discussed, completing the boilerplate sections of those plans and collecting data for progress reports.

鈥淚t is literal night and day,鈥� she says. 鈥淚t鈥檚 also made me realize 鈥� without tooting my own horn 鈥� that I am good at what I do and I do make a difference.鈥�

鈥楾his person has a harder job鈥�

Again, this comes as little surprise to national researchers. Because of the paperwork involved in each student鈥檚 legally required Individualized Education Program, or IEP, special educators must work more hours than other teachers 鈥� almost always for the same pay. Recently, administrators in Hawaii, Detroit and Atlanta have had dramatic success filling vacancies with new hires and licensed special educators already on the payroll but not in classrooms serving disabled kids by offering annual incentives of $10,000, $15,000 and $3,000, respectively.

Only one Minnesota district, St. Paul Public Schools, has tried the approach. Its offer of a $10,000 hiring bonus filled its 70 openings for the 2023-24 school year in a few weeks. 

Historically, school systems are reluctant to consider paying some teachers more than others based on anything but education and experience, says Chad Aldeman, a 74 contributor and researcher who tracks the education labor market. 

鈥淗istorically, unions have opposed offering special incentives for teachers who work in shortage areas or hard-to-staff schools,鈥� he says. 鈥淲e as a country have treated teachers universally and not said, 鈥楾his person has a harder job.鈥欌��

Yet while there is evidence that large financial incentives can be an effective way of filling special education vacancies, new on Hawaii鈥檚 foray into differentiated pay found that it may not significantly impact their retention.   

Teach Plus鈥檚 report also flags teacher training and early career mentorship as factors that educators say would keep them from floundering as they learn the job. Colleges of education vary in how much classroom exposure would-be special education teachers get, with hands-on preparation ranging from a few weeks student teaching under a general education teacher to year-long residencies with a skilled special educator. 

In terms of mentorship, the Illinois survey found that support for some new teachers consisted of brief check-ins 鈥� sometimes consisting of phone calls during the evening commute 鈥� with veteran colleagues. In Minneapolis, Williams said she spent her first year on a team with no one more experienced than her. 

Many states that have confronted special educator shortages chiefly by trying to increase the supply of new teachers. Minnesota advocates have applauded slowly but steadily growing scholarships for teacher candidates who agree to get their special education certification. But they are critical of how officials have expended their energy, complaining that the needs of kids with disabilities have taken a back seat to politics. 

In 2016, in the wake of a decade of lawsuits, legal reforms, and an audit pronouncing the licensing system irretrievably broken, state lawmakers passed a wholesale overhaul, creating a new agency 鈥� the current board 鈥� to oversee it. One of its mandates was to make it more straightforward for teachers of color and nontraditional candidates to enter the classroom. To that end, lawmakers created a system where, depending on their education and experience, potential teachers could start work on a temporary credential and go on to earn a permanent one. 

The new system, which went into effect in 2017, was successful, allowing 2,000 special educators to start work. But last year, based on lobbying from the state鈥檚 traditional colleges of education and the teachers union that also represents their faculty 鈥� who have played a major role on the appointed licensure board 鈥� lawmakers agreed to begin reversing the changes. Next year, board leaders say they plan to seek further contractions.

The irony, say advocates, is that the special educator pipeline is narrowing dramatically even as scant attention is being paid to what equips a new special educator to do a very hard job well, and what might keep them in it. 

鈥淲hat we need to do is really work backward and figure out what creates a high-quality special ed teacher,鈥� says Josh Crosson, executive director of EdAllies, an advocacy group that has been pushing for teacher licensing reforms in Minnesota for more than a decade. 鈥淲hat schools are they [working in]? Are there trends within those schools? What preparation programs are those schools recruiting from? ? Mentorship models? Residency models? 

鈥淲e don’t have any of that data. We’re really just guessing.鈥�

Disclosure: The Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation and Walton Family Foundation provide financial support to Teach Plus, Educators for Excellence, the Center for Learner Equity and The 74. The Carnegie Corporation of New York, the Joyce Foundation and the Charles and Lynn Schusterman Family Philanthropies provide financial support to Teach Plus, Educators for Excellence and The 74. The Mind Trust provides financial support to Teach Plus and The 74. The Nellie Mae Education Foundation provides financial support for Educators for Excellence and The 74.

Get stories like these delivered straight to your inbox. Sign up for The 74 Newsletter